Yusuf - An Other Cup

Yusuf Islam (formerly Cat Stevens) is an incredible songwriter. We know this because he's released a heap of inimitable songs through the years, beginning with his classic album, Tea for the Tillerman, to which, no doubt, his latest effort refers. Where Tea was a refreshing blend of folk and contemporary pop music, infused with the inspirations of nature and peace—two things still vital in his latest album—An Other Cup tastes like what's left in the pot after a long day at work.

Don't get me wrong, there are plenty of moments on this CD where his natural gift shines through, but they are overshadowed by some too-simple songs with grade school-style melodies.

Occasionally, Yusuf will recite a brief poem about something easy and beautiful, like a butterfly. This could be a brilliant moment, but the cheesy instrumentation in the background is disappointing when you know how stunning his work has been in the past. It's hard to listen to An Other Cup and not long for the same artistry that inspired classics like "Wild World" and "Peace Train."

Indeed, the brightest moment on the record is "Don't Let Me Be Misunderstood"—a cover song, performed originally by The Animals and covered over the years by everyone and their brother. Other indications that Islam's star hasn't totally gone out come from "Maybe There's a World," "I Think I See the Light," and the way he craftily incorporates the beautiful language of the Qu'ran.

After 28 years of not releasing records, Yusuf is off to a rusty start with An Other Cup. It's certainly not worth writing off entirely, but just don't expect the same old easy, breezy Cat Stevens record you once loved so much.