Direct to Tape
When Brandi Carlile set out to make a second record, her label suggested she team up with legendary producer T Bone Burnett (Roy Orbison, Elvis Costello, Gillian Welch). Together, Carlile, Burnett, twins Tim and Phil Hanseroth, and the rest of the band, headed out to British Columbia to hole up for two weeks. When they emerged from the studio after this short session, what they had was one of the most authentic Americana records of the year.What's bound to be a focus of many reviews is the fact that Carlile and crew recorded directly to tape this time around, locking them into opportunities for pleasant surprises like "Josephine," which came out in one take, and human mistakes like the crack in Carlile's voice as she goes for the torch note in the title track.
"So Many Stories ..."
What makes the record so great, though, is that, upon a second listen, maybe the stand-out track is "Downpour," or Carlile's personal classic "Turpentine," which she wrote for her brother while still a teenager. The third time through, suddenly the all-acoustic "Cannonball" swings to the fore, with harmonies so strong and gut-wrenching, it's no surprise they were lent to the disc by the Indigo Girls.
Indeed, like any classic record, the songs that stand out here really depend on the listener. In fact, each tune on the disc is its own story about where Carlile has been, and each is equally, hauntingly relatable.
The Bottom Line
It's still very early in Brandi Carlile's career; but where many artists tend to falter with their sophomore albums, Brandi Carlile has only returned stronger, tighter, and more important than before. Her voice is huge, and her skills as a songwriter are equally as poignant. What stands out about The Story is that, like any good story, it may leave you spellbound, surprised, amused, and introspective.
Highlights
- The Story
- Turpentine
- Josephine
- Downpour
- Cannonball
